The Euro has not Worked - even for France
The launch of the single market and the euro have failed to boost trade, jobs and economic growth in the European Union, according to a devastating 2006 report from an official French think-tank. The research, by some of France's most respected economists, was a damning indictment of European economic policy. The report found that, contrary to decades of thinking across Europe, "economic integration has stagnated and no longer promotes growth. The Euro's creation has not produced the knock-on benefits expected...Financial and credit markets remain segmented".
Europhiles, convinced the launch of the Euro would force European governments to reform their failing, high tax and high regulation welfare states, have been proved wrong, the report says. It argues that the single currency has actually had the opposite effect. The report says that:
- No sudden increase in the trade of goods and services has been observed since the euro was introduced in 1999.
- The price convergence that EU monetary union was supposed to bring also did not occur
- The inability of the EU to revive the economy turns investment away from the continent
The report, entitled "Economic Policy and Growth in Europe", is published by the Conseil d'Analyse Economique, chaired by then Prime Minister Dominique de Villepin. The main authors are Philippe Aghion, a Harvard professor; Elie Cohen, research director at Sciences-Po in Paris; and Jean Pisani-Ferry, director of the Bruegel Institute and professor at Paris IX-Dauphine. There are essays by another 10 economists. The CAE includes 40 of France's best-known economists from both the public and the private sectors, the Insee (the equivalent of Britain's Office for National Statistics), the Banque de France and various ministries.
This damning verdict comes from the country which has been one of the most ardent supporters of the EU, and has succeeded in imposing its will in countless EU negotiations. They even insisted that the Governor of the European Central Bank resign half way through his term, to be replaced by a Frenchman. If the French have not benefited, who has?
The Euro has lowered growth in the Eurozone - from an average of 2.4% in the five years before monetary union to 2.1% in the five years after it. The three countries which stayed outside - Britain, Sweden and Denmark - all grew faster.
The Euro always was a Political Project
Continental politicians openly see the Euro as a major step towards a United States of Europe. (see Quotes from EU Leaders) Only in Britain do the politicians pretend it is not happening. Most British people don't want us to lose our independence - they want to keep the pound.
If we join the euro, British economic policy will no longer be decided by a British Government. If we don't like the way British politicians run our economy, we can vote them out. The EU, however, is totally undemocratic - we cannot dismiss any of them. The EU project, captained by unelected bureaucrats with large salaries and pension packages, sails serenely on.
The only good thing about the Euro is that if it breaks up, it will destroy the EU myth, and possibly the EU itself.
We will Leave the European Union - We Want a Referendumn the EUSKeep the Pound.sSay No to the Euro.